Attorney WOUTER MINNIE questions the fairness of World Rugby’s decision to suspend Rassie Erasmus before giving the Springbok coach the opportunity to present his case.
World Rugby’s decision to suspend Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus for six international matches, with immediate effect, has raised an important question that goes beyond rugby: Can someone be found guilty and punished before being given an opportunity to defend himself?
As an attorney, I find the procedure followed in this matter particularly interesting, and potentially concerning, from the perspective of natural justice.
Rassie and I grew up in Despatch and attended the same schools. I mention this simply for transparency. My concern here is not about who is involved, but about the fundamental principles of fairness that should apply equally to everyone.
Let me explain why.
What process did World Rugby follow?
In July 2026, World Rugby introduced a new procedure known as the Match Official Abuse Sanction Process.
Its purpose is to protect match officials against inappropriate public criticism, particularly statements that question their honesty, impartiality or integrity.
Under this process, an independent panel assesses comments made by coaches and other team officials. Depending on its findings, the panel may take no action, issue a warning or impose an automatic suspension.
Importantly, the person sanctioned may then request a full disciplinary hearing to challenge the decision.
And this is where my concern begins.
In Erasmus’ case, an independent panel assessed his comments during a media conference, concluded that they constituted serious misconduct and imposed a six-match suspension with immediate effect.
As far as the publicly available information indicates, Erasmus was not afforded an opportunity to be heard before the sanction was imposed. There is no indication in World Rugby’s published statement that he was invited to present his version, explain the context of his remarks or make representations regarding an appropriate sanction before the panel reached its decision.
World Rugby has confirmed that he is entitled to a full misconduct hearing, and SA Rugby has already requested one.
But surely there is something unusual about making a finding of misconduct, imposing punishment, and only thereafter allowing the accused an opportunity to defend himself?
To me, that appears to be putting the cart before the horse.
What happened to the principles of natural justice?
One of the most fundamental principles of our legal system is the Latin maxim audi alteram partem which literally means “hear the other side.”
In simple terms, before a decision is made that adversely affects someone, that person should ordinarily be given a reasonable opportunity to know the allegations against them and respond.
This principle is not unique to South African law. It is equally recognised in English common law, which governs World Rugby’s regulatory framework.
It is also expressly recognised in World Rugby’s own disciplinary regulations.
Regulation 20.6.1(c), for example, requires that a person facing disciplinary proceedings be afforded a reasonable opportunity to be informed of the charges, be heard and present their case.
Regulation 18.10.1 also provides for representations concerning an appropriate sanction once misconduct has been established.
The principle is straightforward: fairness requires more than an independent person making a decision. It requires a fair procedure.
An independent panel is not necessarily a procedurally fair panel simply because its members are independent.
But Erasmus can still challenge the decision, can’t he?
Yes, and this is an important qualification.
English law recognises that, in certain circumstances, defects in an initial disciplinary process may be remedied through a subsequent, genuinely fair hearing.
Therefore, I am not suggesting that World Rugby’s new procedure is automatically unlawful merely because a full hearing does not take place beforehand.
The crucial question is whether the process, considered as a whole, affords the affected person a meaningful and effective opportunity to defend himself.
But consider the practical position here.
Erasmus has already been suspended. The finding has already been made. The punishment has already taken effect.
He must now initiate further proceedings to challenge a decision which, on the information presently available, was reached without first affording him an opportunity to explain or defend his position.
Even if the subsequent committee approaches the matter entirely afresh, the question remains whether justice has been served if part of the punishment has already been enforced.
And what about the timing?
This is another aspect that concerns me.
The suspension was announced on Tuesday, 17 November 2026, just four days before the Springboks are scheduled to face Ireland in Dublin on Saturday, 21 November.
Ireland is one of the world’s leading rugby nations, and this is an important international fixture.
The sanction prevents Erasmus from performing his normal match-day coaching duties and even from entering the stadium.
World Rugby’s statement explains why the panel regarded his comments as serious misconduct. It also refers to the timing and reach of his remarks as considerations in determining the sanction.
However, the public statement does not explain whether the panel considered the immediate consequences of excluding the Springbok head coach from such an important fixture before he had exercised his right to a full hearing.
I am certainly not suggesting, without evidence, that the timing was deliberately intended to disadvantage South Africa.
But the timing does raise a legitimate question about procedural fairness.
What happens if Erasmus successfully challenges the suspension next week, but has already missed Saturday’s match?
That opportunity cannot be restored.
A subsequent finding in his favour would not necessarily undo the prejudice already suffered.
What about the actual concerns Erasmus raised?
There is another issue that deserves attention.
Erasmus questioned the apparent failure of match officials, particularly the television match official (TMO), to intervene in what he believed were numerous dangerous knee-drop tackles during South Africa’s defeat to France.
His comments included a suggestion that knowingly ignoring such incidents could amount to interfering with the outcome of a match.
These are serious remarks. I do not suggest that coaches should be permitted to accuse match officials of dishonesty or deliberate manipulation without consequences.
Match officials deserve respect and protection against abuse.
However, Erasmus also raised concerns about player safety, consistency in officiating and the application of the laws of the game.
Those concerns deserve to be distinguished from the language he used to express them.
World Rugby’s disciplinary statement concentrates on the remarks, the perceived attack on match officials’ integrity and the resulting sanction.
It does not provide a substantive public response to the underlying concerns about the alleged dangerous tackles, whether those incidents were reviewed, or whether the officiating was consistent with World Rugby’s own directives.
I appreciate that a disciplinary statement is not necessarily the appropriate forum for resolving every refereeing complaint. Nevertheless, the underlying player-safety concerns should not simply disappear because the coach’s choice of words attracted disciplinary action.
It should be possible to hold a coach accountable for inappropriate remarks while also properly examining the concerns that prompted those remarks.
The two issues are not mutually exclusive.
My conclusion
World Rugby undoubtedly has a legitimate interest in protecting the integrity of rugby and its match officials.
Equally, disciplinary proceedings must be conducted fairly.
The existence of a disciplinary procedure does not automatically establish that the procedure satisfies the principles of natural justice.
What concerns me is not merely the six-match suspension, but the apparent sequence of events: an adverse finding, an immediately enforceable punishment, and only thereafter an opportunity to be heard.
Whether this process ultimately satisfies the requirements of English law will depend, among other things, on the precise rules governing it, the scope of the subsequent hearing and whether that hearing provides an effective remedy before irreversible prejudice occurs.
I am not suggesting that Erasmus is necessarily innocent of misconduct or that World Rugby’s decision is automatically invalid. Those are questions requiring proper consideration.
My concern is more fundamental.
If we accept that every person deserves a fair opportunity to defend himself, should that opportunity not ordinarily be afforded before punishment is imposed, rather than afterwards?
That is the question I believe World Rugby’s new disciplinary process needs to answer.
Because ultimately, justice is not simply about reaching the correct decision.
It is also about following a fair process to get there.
And that principle should apply regardless of whether the person involved is Rassie Erasmus, another international coach, or an ordinary employee facing disciplinary proceedings.
Natural justice is not something we demand only for people we know or support. It is a fundamental principle that should apply to everyone including those whose conduct we may disagree with.
REVEALED: The 17 tackles that angered Erasmus
Photos: Supplied/Dan Clohessy/Gallo Images
Crédito: Link de origem