Continental Postal Services of Hebland

Sierra Leone In 2025: A Critical Analysis of “Vision 2025”

After a protracted civil war (1991–2002), Sierra Leone embarked on a very ambitious post-war peace-building and national development agenda. Key among the strategies employed is the Vision 2025 document, put forward in 2003 under then President Ahmed Tejan Kabbah, which highlighted four possible future scenarios – from best-case (Sweet-Salone) to worst-case (Dombolo) – where Sierra Leone could find itself by 2025.

While no one particular group came up with these scenarios, the scenario construction framework was drawn from the UNDP’s African Future Project that was spearheaded by Professor Alioune Sall. The four scenarios were developed through a participatory national visioning process. Thus, they were the outcome of collective work led by the government through Dr. Kadi Sesay (then Minister of Development and Economic Planning), a National Core Team (NCT) comprised of cultural, gender, agricultural, tourism and political experts, specialist groups, UNDP, and over 8,000 Sierra Leoneans from different regions and backgrounds through workshops, essay competitions and radio programs.

As we enter 2026, this essay presents a critical analysis of the country’s progress in relation to Vision 2025, focusing on governance and competitive economic growth. It positions Sierra Leone within the vision’s framework, assessing whether the country’s developmental path reflects sustainable development, stagnation, or systemic fragility altogether.

Vision 2025: Scenarios and Expectations

The Vision 2025 framework outlines four possible scenarios:

  1. Sweet-Salone: equitable governance, strong economic growth, investor confidence, institutional legitimacy, and broad development gains.
  2. Betteh-Nor-Dae: moderate progress with governance and development constraints that dampen investor enthusiasm and long-term sustainability.
  3. Tight-Gentry: periods of political instability, potential authoritarian impulses, and structural inefficiencies.
  4. Dombolo: deep socio-political regression, conflict resurgence, and institutional collapse.

In his book, Professor Alioune Sall clustered the possible futures of Africa into four categories using a lion metaphor to symbolize Africa’s potential and challenges. The four scenarios Prof. Sall and his team identified are: The Lions Are Trapped, The Lions Are Hungry, The Lions Come Out of Their Den, and The Lions Mark Their Territory. The scenario framework from Professor Sall feeds directly into Sierra Leone’s framework.

While Sierra Leone did not use the lion metaphor, it instead used localized names that resonated with the country’s people. For instance, Sweet-Salone is a term that Sierra Leoneans use every day to describe the country when things seem to be going in the right direction. This particular scenario fits well with Professor Sall’s metaphor of “the lions mark their territory” – here, Africa is assertive, confident and shapes its destiny.

Betteh-Nor-Dae is another phrase that Sierra Leoneans use when things are happening but there is room for improvement. It translates to “I don’t have enough but you can manage this little that I have.” This scenario is in line with the “lions come out of their den” metaphor of Prof. Sall. In this scenario, Africa is emerging with reform-driven progress.

Tight-Gentry is another popular Sierra Leonean phrase that translates to restrictive wealth. It basically means that the country is at peace but pressure for change (economic, social and political) risks instability. This scenario is drawn from Prof. Sall’s metaphor where “the lions are hungry.” In this scenario, Africa faces pressure from its people over unmet needs that risks instability.

Finally, Dombolo is a local word in Sierra Leone that means danger. This is the worst-case scenario according to Vision 2025. In this scenario, Sierra Leone returns to conflict despite years of post-war reconstruction and development. The “Dombolo” scenario is equivalent to “The Lions Are Trapped” metaphor of Professor Sall, where Africa as a continent experiences destabilized states that are engulfed in wars and economic collapse.

Sierra Leone does not lack good policies; rather, the implementation of these policies has always been the issue. For example, Vision 2025 made provision for the creation of a National Vision Council (NVC) that was supposed to be chaired by a “well-respected, non-partisan, dignified Sierra Leonean” who would be responsible for tracking progress. This council was, however, never created. Instead, its responsibilities were subsumed into the Ministry of Development and Economic Planning. The implications for this are: an accountability gap, since there is no dedicated non-partisan national group to provide oversight; uneven monitoring, as different MDAs provide their reporting; and a shift to new frameworks, as the country aligned its development programs to the MDGs and SDGs, etc.

Additionally, development – whether human or economic – is a very expensive endeavour. Thus, policymakers need to provide the actual cost of undertaking any development activity and a feasible financing mechanism to achieve it. This is important, as most political leaders tend to make ambitious promises during campaign periods without a properly worked-out financing mechanism for their development programs.

These four scenarios highlight the interconnectedness and interdependence of political stability, governance quality, economic performance, and public trust in institutions.

Politics & Governance

Since 2003, Sierra Leone has witnessed four consecutive elections, resulting in the transfer of political power to three governments. However, while the June 2023 general elections saw the incumbent Julius Maada Bio of the Sierra Leone People’s Party (SLPP) get re-elected and his party gain a majority of parliamentary seats, the aftermath of the elections unmasked huge challenges in the administration of elections and trust in public institutions.

Numerous independent observers, including the European Union, agreed that there was a lack of adequate transparency in communicating and publishing disaggregated results, which eroded stakeholders’ confidence in the entire process. According to Afrobarometer (2025), between 2018 and 2025, public trust in the Electoral Commission for Sierra Leone has almost dwindled by half, suggesting a declining perception of impartiality and performance.

The main opposition APC party has on numerous occasions raised concerns over electoral data verification and transparency, leading them at times to suspend their participation in the Tripartite Committee – a post-election reform committee – whenever there is a gridlock. This polarization points to a profound systemic skepticism about the fairness and quality of election bodies.

The fundamental aim of the Tripartite Committee is to proffer institutional and legal reforms, but it has been facing immense challenges in implementing its mandates even after two years of its inception. Some groups such as ISS Africa have even argued that amending legal instruments such as the national constitution is imperative for addressing core governance shortcomings, implying that focusing only on procedural reforms without looking at the underlying structural constitutional change will only create superficial gains.

In the area of judicial independence, there is still overwhelming debate about the impartiality of the judiciary in handling politically sensitive cases. Up until now, political parties still distrust the ability of the judiciary to address their grievances, thus weakening a pivotal component of democratic accountability and consolidation.

In addition, the removal of Vice President Sam Sumana from office in 2015 by former President Ernest Bai Koroma set a dangerous political precedent. While the former president cited “neglect of duties” by Sam Sumana after he went to seek asylum at the American embassy as the reason for his dismissal, rulings from the ECOWAS Regional Court later found the sacking to be illegal.

These incidents revealed early fundamental weaknesses in governance, a lack of respect for the rule of law and access to a fair trial that Vision 2025 aimed to overcome by establishing strong, credible democratic institutions.

Furthermore, there has been heavy scrutiny of the independence of key institutions that were set up as accountability mechanisms. For instance, the suspension and eventual removal of the Auditor-General – someone recognized internationally for her sterling audit work – has raised concerns about balancing political influence and constitutional procedure. In fact, many people seem to agree that procedural opacities and political interference reduced the perceived independence of the Audit Service, a pivotal institution in holding the government accountable.

In light of everything that has been happening, including but not limited to disputes about elections and institutional contestations, highly polarized citizens’ perceptions of the governance architecture have all culminated in dwindling public trust in state institutions. A 2025 study by Afrobarometer is also in agreement with this claim. The study indicates declining faith in parliament, the electoral commission and key government institutions.

These patterns point to a trust problem that hampers the sense of collective national identity and erodes the perceived credibility of governance decisions and outcomes. In the Betteh-Nor-Dae scenario of the Vision 2025 framework, this particular outcome is expected. In such a scenario, overall societal gains are hindered by institutional challenges, thereby undermining societal cohesion and investor confidence.

Competitive Economic Growth

From a microeconomic perspective, Sierra Leone seems to be making tentative but positive progress, with the IMF predicting falling inflation and rising economic growth underpinned by reforms from the Extended Credit Facility arrangement.

However, subsistence agriculture and heavy reliance on the extractive industries have historically made the country prone to shocks. In addition, infrastructural deficits, high levels of poverty and low human capital development continue to hamper inclusive, sustainable development, thereby making the country’s economic growth topsy-turvy.

For instance, just after the conflict, Sierra Leone saw a revamp in economic productivity. The return to normalcy made room for mining and agriculture to drive GDP growth – moving from 4.3 percent in 2002, to 9 percent in 2003, to 7 percent in 2004. By the 2010s, the country witnessed real GDP expansion, with growth reaching 7 percent for several years – some estimates even claimed it peaked in double digits. However, these growth levels were disrupted by the 2014–2015 Ebola outbreak.

After the Ebola outbreak, growth was mostly moderate, ranging from 2–6 percent before the COVID-19 pandemic. Nevertheless, the COVID-19 pandemic impacted economic growth, leading to a contraction of -1.39 percent. On the other hand, the economy made a strong rebound of 5–6 percent growth between 2021 and 2022. This growth was also short-lived, as projections show it dwindled to around 4.4 percent in 2025.

The above-stated data point to volatility in the economy, as the country has yet to put adequate measures in place to prevent both internal and external shocks. While enormous strides have been made, more needs to be done to lead to competitive economic growth. For instance, to address unemployment, World Bank estimates suggest that the economy needs to create at least 75,000 jobs each year to maintain a stable employment-to-population ratio. This estimate is even lower than the current administration’s goal of 83,000 jobs to reach 500,000 by 2030.

Hence, one of the pillars of the government Youth Employment Scheme (YES) key actions is to give tax incentives to companies hiring youth and graduates. While this is an excellent initiative to attract companies, the general investment climate needs to be improved. For instance, the First Lady’s involvement in the issues between workers of Koidu Limited and the company indirectly led to the company shutdown and the eventual summary dismissal of over 1,000 local workers.

Another problem is that enough mechanisms have not been put in place to address issues related to mining companies and the communities in which they operate, despite persistent disputes. For instance, the 2007 Koidu-Sefadu protest, where protesters tried to forcefully enter the mine – arguing the mining company was responsible for destroying the environment – eventually led to the deaths of two people and several injuries caused by the police. Similarly, in 2012, there was a protest by African Minerals Limited workers against the company for maltreatment and discrimination that led to the killing of a 24-year-old woman by the police.

In order to address all mining-related problems, Sierra Leone could learn from Ghana, as it has implemented reforms that have led to a significant reduction in such incidents. It has succeeded in implementing legal reforms that seek to increase royalties that benefit local and national development, and created community livelihood diversification programs in mining regions to reduce dependency on unstable mining jobs. Sierra Leone could also create a formal multi-stakeholder grievance mechanism that will serve as a body where communities and workers can raise their concerns with neutral oversight before they are escalated. This will reduce the whole idea of ‘security first’ that usually tends to intensify conflict.

In light of everything that has been happening since the design of the vision, the aspirations of Vision 2025 for wider economic transformation partly remain unachieved, and growth is yet to be translated into meaningful job creation, private sector vitality, or export diversification.

Situating Sierra Leone within the Vision 2025 scenarios

Evaluating these developments in relation to the Vision 2025 scenarios, the picture that emerges is a nuanced one:

  • Not Sweet-Salone: persistent institutional mistrust, unresolved governance reforms, and contested electoral legitimacy fall short of the best scenario’s anticipation of inclusive and credible governance.
  • Not Dombolo: there are no apparent signs of a return to widespread conflict or systematic breakdown; democratic processes remain intact and state institutions are still functioning.
  • Not Tight-Gentry: the country has avoided severe authoritarian backsliding or military interventions that would override constitutional rule.
  • In accordance with Betteh-Nor-Dae: while there has been some moderate progress, institutional and governance challenges persist, and concerns over trust and legitimacy largely remain unresolved.

All things considered, Sierra Leone appears to be following a strained version of the Betteh-Nor-Dae scenario, one that reflects tangible stability and development but is constrained by institutional fragility and diminishing public trust. However, this essay does not claim to perform a complete diagnosis of the problem. Instead, it has only tried to raise awareness of the subject matter.

Moving forward

The political climate in Sierra Leone needs to be sanitized. This is because no lasting development can be achieved in a highly polarized climate. The current constitutional review process is making provision for the creation of a Search and Nomination Committee (SNC) by the president to nominate the commissioner of the National Electoral Commission (NEC). It will comprise one person representing the inter-religious community; one legal practitioner qualified to be a judge of the High Court of Sierra Leone; one person representing civil society; one person from the private sector, labour congress or chambers of commerce; one person representing youth groups; one person practicing as a qualified journalist in Sierra Leone; and three persons representing women’s organizations.

This is in contrast to the 1991 Constitution, where the president appoints the commissioner himself after consultation with the leaders of registered political parties. The creation of a neutral, non-partisan body is a step in the right direction because the appointment of Mohamed Kanneh in 2020 was not only challenged by the main opposition APC, as the party was not consulted before his appointment, but the 2023 election he conducted has been dubbed one of the most controversial elections in recent history.

In addition, investors need a stable and predictable business climate before investing their resources in any country. In fact, a 2019 study of 100 dictatorial countries found that dictatorships with educated leaders attract more foreign direct investment than unstable democracies. While this does not mean investors prefer dictatorship or autocracy to democracy, the preference is for stability and predictability in the business environment. Another study in 2025 also found that multinational investors may prefer autocratic countries because they provide streamlined investment climates and experience fewer political challenges.

While this is not an endorsement of autocracy or dictatorship, the emphasis is on creating a stable democracy that produces strong institutions whose actions can restore investors’ confidence and provide a stable and predictable business environment. This is because the main job of the government in the economy is to provide an enabling business environment, while the private sector provides the investment and innovation necessary for economic growth.

Lastly, ‘vision thinking’ is a very important tool for envisioning development outcomes. It enables policymakers to see the possible outcomes of their policies, thereby enabling them to discern alternative outcomes. In Africa, most policy implementations are thought of in a linear and waterfall manner, making them hard to track and readjust before completion. Employing ‘vision thinking’ is not only important for predicting future scenarios but also serves as a tool to track them. So, a similar vision can be undertaken, learning from the successes and failures of Vision 2025.

Conclusion

As Sierra Leone concludes the chapter on Vision 2025, the evidence demonstrates substantive advances in microeconomic stabilization, the preservation of post-war peace, and continuity of formal political processes. Nonetheless, dwindling institutional trust, electoral transparency, and governance accountability remain huge obstacles to the realization of the framework’s envisioned outcomes.

The prevailing context – characterized by electoral contestation, dwindling trust in core state institutions, enigmatic accountability dynamics, and prolonged diplomatic tensions – simultaneously underscores both the resilience of Sierra Leone’s post-war system and the depth of its structural vulnerabilities. Moving forward, tackling these governance and legitimacy issues will be crucial to the design of any successive development framework, whether framed through Vision 2040 or alternative national strategies.

Issa Darlington Kamara is a junior lecturer who teaches Politics and Democracy at the Development Studies Department, University of Makeni.

Credit: Source link

Comments are closed.